
Sometimes insights into history emerge from the most unexpected places at the most unexpected times. That happened to me recently during a casual conversation with an acquaintance that highlighted the importance of shared values for political parties.
He has been an avid Trump supporter, but when we were talking about the Iran war he blindsided me. He expressed some doubts about Trump’s remarks about wiping Iran off the map and his feud with the Pope. The source of these doubts was former Faux News commentator Tucker Carlson, whose objections to the war and his new doubts about Trump are all over the Internet.
From a historical perspective, this suggested a far different and more nuanced perspective about Trump’s support than I have seen. But then most reporters rarely spend much time in the Midwest and certainly not with people like my acquaintance. It appears their loyalty and trust may not be to Trump personally, but to certain commentators and sources such as social media and Faux News. The pundits may be profoundly misinterpreting what has usually been viewed as a rock-solid Trump base.
It’s What Happens to Lame Ducks
Trump has always been a media creature. Faux News and social media made him, but what happens when those who made him begin to have doubts? History is instructive. When autocrats and despots age or face hurdles like term limits, the sharks begin to circle, waiting for their chance. With talk about a third Trump term seeming even more ridiculous than when it was first proposed, the President is now approaching the halfway point of a lame duck administration. Expect to see more defections, more cabinet resignations, as those who hope to inherit his mantle jockey for position, especially if the Republicans lose seats and perhaps their majority.
We tend to forget that it was Faux News algorithms that turned immigration into a hot-button issue before Donald Trump picked it up. Every crime—and especially the most gory ones—committed by an illegal immigrant was treated as THE biggest story of the day. Faux viewers endured graphic descriptions of alleged crimes (remember the controversy about immigrants eating pets) underscored by the constant refrain that every problem in this country was due to immigrants.
There is nothing new in this. Newspapers and even political parties like the Know-Nothings stirred up anti-immigrant prejudices during the nineteenth century when immigration was at its highest level. During the peak year of 1882, immigrants amounted to 1.5% of the total population, a figure that would total 4.9 million new Americans today. Imagine what Faux News would do with that.
What made Faux immigration coverage more dangerous than nineteenth century rants was that it was on the air 24 hours a day, every day. Ever the opportunist, Donald Trump anchored his campaigns and subsequent administrations on this anti-immigrant feeling. Immigration, of course, was Tucker Carlson’s meat and potatoes as he built his reputation on anti-immigrant tirades, terming immigration as an “illegal invasion,” a charge repeated by the President as his justification for the draconian methods of ICE thugs.
The Feud
Carlson’s doubts have precipitated a feud with the current occupant of the now-gilded White House, who has openly disparaged Carlson, calling him “low-IQ” and “highly overrated.” The spectacle of a dogfight between Carlson & Trump has preoccupied the media and emboldened Democrats, but the bigger question is what will people whose loyalty is to Carlson, and not Trump, decide to do next November?
In his current “confessional” mode, Carlson has not disavowed any of his rants about immigration and other issues, even as he has expressed doubts about Trump. This is important for divining the future of any Trump supporters who also have doubts about the President. It seems highly unlikely they will suddenly disavow the Republican Party. Nor will they change their attitudes about hot-button Carlson diatribes.
So what are we to make of Carlson’s newfound doubts? My guess is the former Faux commentator is already thinking about the future after Trump. His “confessional” is the first of what will be more doubts about a lame-duck President who appears increasingly unhinged as he ponders fading into the sunset. The logical choice to benefit from Carlson’s support would be J.D. Vance, whom he has openly admired, but Carlson’s son recently resigned his position in Vance’s office. It would not be out of the question for Carlson to be preparing the ground for himself. After all, the current occupant of the White House rose on the strength of his media persona.
Democrats Continue to Wobble
Any possibility Democrats will capitalize on the feud is complicated by a lack of shared values in their own party that was highlighted when Bernie Sanders called on the party to disavow Super PAC money from big corporations. Sanders and Senators Merkley, Smith, Warren, Welch, and Van Hollen sent a letter to Chuck Schumer and Democratic National Committee head Ken Martin stating:
Corporate-funded super PACs are shaping the 2026 elections as we speak, and the scale of their resources is unprecedented,
This letter is the Democratic equivalent to the Carlson “confession.” For the opposition, it highlights a longstanding party rift between the pro-business Clinton New Democrats and progresives. In my home state of Minnesota this has resulted in Angie Craig giving up the House seat she probably would have won again to take on Peggy Flanagan in a race for a United States Senate seat. Craig is backed by Schumer and hefty contributions from the crypto industry. The Sanders letter referred to such races when it noted:
Crypto-aligned groups are preparing to spend $200 million, and AIPAC-affiliated groups already control more than $90 million. The AI industry has already spent over $185 million this year alone. These sums are being deployed to influence Democratic primaries and overwhelm candidates who rely on grassroots support.
Such intra-party fights highlight the rift in a party that a little more than six months before the midterm elections, still lacks a unified message. Sorry, but affordability is no message, especially without any specifics about how the party aims to solve the problem. In addition, the party has not shown much spine in opposing the administration in Congress. Polls show the results of the lack of a unified message, with potential voters holding the party at the lowest level in the history of CNN polling.
People may despise the President and Carlson, but one thing even the haters can agree on is that both have principles, even if those principles are not ones they can support. Business consultants often like to highlight “shared values” in their PowerPoints, but can anyone define the core value of the current Democratic Party in a simple sentence? My guess is they would have no trouble doing this with either Carlson or Trump.
For Democrats, values have become like a third rail they will not touch–especially what used to be the party’s central message of a level playing field. Unless that changes, their best hope for November is that voters will cast their ballots against the mess in the White House. The Democrats might recapture a majority in one or both houses of Congress, but once in power they will lack a sense of direction to guide them through the barbed thicket of Italian-suited corporate lobbyists and the smothering vines of no compromise single interest groups entangling Washington.
