
Image: Mary Septak from The Century, March 1898.
To celebrate this week’s release of my book The Age of Discontent, I want to honor the people who are its central focus, the Discontented. During the thirteen years I have spent with them, I came to admire their resiliency, courage, and creativity.
They numbered in so many thousands they became this country’s greatest popular uprising as discontent built up under economic and social pressures generated by the tension between the promise of progress and the realities of their own lives. They met in churches and saloons, whispered new ideas a mile underground, and shouted fighting words under the unforgiving sun of the prairies. They were murdered, beaten, blackballed, cheated, and humiliated, but they refused to surrender. Though flawed, they strove to rebuild their country in a world never imagined by the Founders. How could the constitutional compromises of gentlemen in powdered wigs apply to Western Union, the Associated Press, locomotives traveling a mile a minute, steel mills that could swallow an ocean liner, and dynamos that stopped nearby watches?
The fiery furnaces of the late nineteenth century forged the Discontented into a compound as strong as the steel forged in Andrew Carnegie’s smoke-belching mills. Many of those who became leaders of the Discontented went through conversion experiences where they endured a life-numbing tragedy that sent them into a purgatory where they wandered seeking answers. When they emerged, they brought with them a deeper understanding of themselves and the world they faced, tempered by a staunch conviction that can only come from having overcome the unspeakable.
Leonora Barry lost her husband and took a factory job to feed her family only to be blackballed after a strike. She found her calling organizing other women and becoming the most effective speaker for the Knights of Labor. After Mary Lease lost her farm she wandered the Midwestern frontier seeking answers emerging like a Biblical prophet to hurl oratorical thunderbolts on behalf of Midwestern farmers. Knights of Labor leader Terence Powderly was thrown out of work by the Panic of 1873, so he walked to Canada, picking up odd jobs, including playing nursemaid to a herd of pigs for 75¢ a day. He described hitting bottom: “I have sampled in all its awful reality the desolation and misery of tramp life that at times, during blinding storms of sleet and snow, seemed to shut out all sight and sound and hope of God.”
A Queen Who Rules with a High Hand
A member of the Discontented who caught my attention was Slav immigrant boarding house owner, miner’s wife, and union activist Mary Septak. She lived in the Pennsylvania anthracite mining town of Lattimer, where the tilt of the playing field was especially pronounced, something recognized by area newspapers: “No part of the world ever presented so favorable an opportunity as the coal regions for the rich to oppress the poor working man. In many instances, the opportunity was not neglected.” Only the strong survived the harsh realities of these company towns, where coal dust transformed trees into skeletons and converted streams into inky, foul-smelling tributaries similar to the River Styx. Curses accompanied the ritual scrubbing of blackness from clothes and walls, but prayers could not prevent it from coating a miner’s lungs.

Image: Slav miners, Lattimer, Pennsylvania
She was known as Big Mary, “the most forcible and picturesque character of the mining region . . . a queen who rules with a high hand.” She relished how the feared mine police avoided eye contact because her eyes said, “I will not be broken.” A sketch shows a dark-haired woman with a light-colored kerchief proclaiming the melting pot’s limits. Although The Century called her an “Amazon” whose words were “well punctuated by profanity,” it also depicted tender moments. “As [her husband] passes her from time to time,” observed the writer, “he says some pleasant word or pats her cheek.”
In 1897, Septak helped organize one of the most crucial labor actions of the Age of Discontent in response to one of its most horrific events. On a warm September day, a group of unarmed, striking miners marched to the Lattimer mine carrying an American flag on a skeletal tree limb. Lining the road outside town were a mob of “deputies” carrying sixteen-shot Winchesters newly purchased by mine owners. At least nineteen died and dozens more were wounded when the deputies opened fire. Many were shot in the back, some multiple times, as the deputies reloaded and continued firing on the helpless workers, many of whom cried out in languages other than English.
In the aftermath, Mary Septak and other women symbolically picked up the flag that fell in that massacre to continue the strike. As well organized as a crack regiment, they executed a series of guerrilla actions that confounded National Guard troops. Septak’s army outflanked them by moving south to Carbon County, where the military had no jurisdiction. They drove out replacement workers at the Bunker Hill and Honey Brook mines by creating a diversion that allowed a larger force to close them down. They did all this without cars to carry them or cell phones to coordinate them. The climax occurred at Lattimer, where Guard General John Gobin ordered his troops to fix their bayonets. Accounts of rifles glinting in the sun opposing women armed with rolling pins, broomsticks, and fire pokers worked on readers.
The outgunned women lost that battle and the strike as the miners trudged back to work carrying their lunch pails. Mine owners may have celebrated the victory, but they had lost the war. The women dramatized that jobs were not about wages but survival. Despite losing the strike, the women’s actions revived the United Mine Workers (UMW), which gained 10,000 members in Pennsylvania alone after their actions.
In “Gilded Age” histories that focus on the tycoons you will not find any mention of the women’s strike, perhaps because its repercussions were not felt until five years later when the miner’s emerged victorious in what labor leader Samuel Gompers termed the most important strike in American history. For UMW leader John Mitchell it was a “second emancipation.”
Spontaneous Uprisings
Today, something is stirring in this country that echoes the Discontented. The people are waking up. In spontaneous uprisings, people pack town hall meetings, even when Republicans are afraid to hold them. People MSNBC commentator Rachel Maddow terms “America’s new political leadership” are registering their discontent with the autocratic actions of the new administration and the impotence of both parties in Congress.

They are rallying outside Tesla dealers, causing Musk’s stock to drop and people to trade in their cars. They are standing outside Social Security offices to express their anger at cuts in funding and staff. They are turning out on college campuses to oppose the illegal detention and deportation of immigrants. They are packing town halls to shout their anger at the representatives and senators who lack the courage to stand up for the Constitution.
It is still too early to know if this will morph into a new generation of discontented. It is now up to the rest of us to support the thousands of anonymous who have shown up, as their ancestors did before them, to defend the Constitution and battle to level a playing field badly tilted against them. Mary Septak and the rest of the Discontented offer lessons for the new discontented about the importance of patience, resiliency, and commitment.
In our world of instant news, it is easy to forget change does not take place overnight. Mitchell’s Second Emancipation came three decades after the formation of the Working Men’s Benevolent Association, the miner’s union that preceded the UMW. Septak and the other women could have easily given up after the horrors of the Lattimer Massacre. After being driven off at the point of a bayonet, they could have concluded further resistance was pointless. Yet they and their miner husbands successfully managed a strike involving over 100,000 workers.
If the Discontented leave one message, it is that anything is possible for any one of us. Mary Lease advised, “Keep your eyes fixed on the mark, and don’t flinch when you pull the trigger.” She and others illustrate how we fulfill a dream by acting on it, and by not giving up. That lies behind Thomas Jefferson’s imperative that each generation must apply America’s principles to the challenges of a changing world. The late nineteenth century met that test. Now it is our turn.
